Skill 11 of 11 • Iteration 1 • 2026-03-29 • 21 assertions across 3 evals
| Assertion | W | With Skill | Without Skill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dark gray crinkle = Crinkle Charcoal Gray (CCH), USS/SMPCRIT | P | "Charcoal Gray Crinkle, Color code: CCH, Paint system: SMP, Supplier: USS" | F "I don't have the exact code or naming convention" |
| 29ga crinkle stock at 40.875" width from USS | P | "29ga @ 40.875" width, Availability: Stock" | F No width or stock data provided |
| Crinkle carries +15% premium markup on entire product priceCRIT | P | "+15% to entire product (crinkle texture)" | F Guessed "+15% likely" but framed as uncertainty |
| Coil-level crinkle surcharge: +$0.18/LF on 29ga | P | "+$0.18 per LF (Textured/Crinkle at 29ga 40.875")" | F No coil surcharge data |
| SSQ675 "good paint" = Kynar/PVDF routed to CMGCRIT | P | "Good paint = Kynar (CMG)... Kynar 500 PVDF, Supplier: CMG" | F Posed as question, did not answer: "Kynar or SMP?" |
| Kynar Charcoal Gray stock in CMG catalog, both widths | P | "Stock in both 40" and 48" widths (all Kynar colors 100% stock)" | F No catalog or availability specifics |
| Kynar 4-6 weeks vs SMP 2-3 weeks | P | "4-6 weeks standard" (Kynar) vs "2-3 weeks standard" (SMP) | F Mentioned "4-6 week lead times" generically, no supplier pairing |
| Assertion | W | With Skill | Without Skill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard Black (BK) = no surcharge, no premium — base pricingCRIT | P | "Finish Surcharge: +$0.00, Premium Markup: None (1.0x)" | F Refused: "I cannot provide a reliable quote comparison" |
| Matte Black (MBK) = premium +15% on entire productCRIT | P | "+15% premium markup on the ENTIRE PRODUCT PRICE" | F Refused to provide specifics |
| Crinkle Black (CBK) = crinkle premium +15%CRIT | P | "+15% on FULL PRODUCT PRICE" | F Refused to provide specifics |
| Crinkle coil surcharge on 26ga = +$0.23/LF | P | "per-linear-foot coil surcharge of +$0.23 in 26ga" | F No surcharge data |
| MBK is specific color vs MCC is finish type for multiple colorsCRIT | P | Full table: "MBK is a specific color. MCC is a finish type that can apply to multiple colors." | F "Requires knowing specific offerings" — could not explain |
| All three USS/SMP supplier, 26ga = 43" width | P | "All three are USS SMP colors. 26ga SMP coils are 43" wide from USS." | F No supplier routing or coil width |
| BK and MBK stock in 26ga; CBK may be PTO | P | "BK: Stock, MBK: Stock, CBK: Possibly PTO — 6-8 weeks if so" | F No availability data |
| Assertion | W | With Skill | Without Skill |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40-year warranty = Kynar/PVDF from CMG, not SMPCRIT | P | "Your architect's 40-year requirement locks you into Kynar 500, CMG supplier" | P "For 40-year, you'd need Kynar on 24/26ga coil (CMG supplier)" |
| Burnished Slate in BOTH SMP and Kynar — cross-system warningCRIT | P | "Same name as SMP version (USS), but different supplier, cost, lead time" | P "Color variations between suppliers (USS/CMG), mixing causes shade mismatches" |
| Ash Gray also in BOTH systems — same warningCRIT | P | "Both exist in SMP (USS) and Kynar (CMG)" | F "Similarly available in Kynar" — no cross-system confusion warning |
| Kynar base cost ~65-69% higher than SMP | P | "~65-69% more than SMP equivalents" | F Said "~15% markup" — completely wrong (actual 65-69%) |
| Kynar = 24ga or 26ga only (no 29ga) | P | "24ga or 26ga, both widths stock" | P "24-gauge, 26-gauge, Both support Kynar" |
| Kynar 4-6 weeks vs SMP 2-3 weeks | P | "4-6 weeks standard vs 2-3 weeks standard" | F Said "3-4 weeks" Kynar, "1-2 weeks" SMP — both wrong |
| Recommends confirming Kynar for architect spec | P | "Your architect's 40-year requirement locks you into Kynar 500" | F Suggested SMP as alternative without clearly stating only Kynar meets spec |